
I finished listening to Outlander, the first book in Diana Gabaldon’s epic series, a couple of days ago. I enjoyed experiencing it on audiobook this time, especially since Davina Porter, who reads the book, is one of the best audiobook narrators I’ve ever heard.
Most of you know the plot of Outlander: Claire Randall, a married nurse, is on a holiday with her husband Frank, trying to reconnect after years of separation during WW II. They are vacationing in Scotland when Claire discovers a circle of standing stones, a henge. Claire disappears through the stones, arriving in Scotland two hundred years earlier, a couple years before the Scottish Uprising and the devastating battle of Culloden.
Claire is found by the ruthless MacKenzie clan, and is given in marriage to young Jamie Frasier, a man wanted for murder. Claire, who loves her husband Frank, finds herself falling for her new husband. The love Claire experiences with Jamie completely outshines and overshadows the relationship she had with Frank, and when faced with the opportunity to return to her own time, Claire opts to remain with Jamie. She is then faced with the question of what she should do with the knowledge she possesses - especially when some of her kinsman-by-marriage will most likely be involved in The Uprising.
I enjoyed Outlander very much, even having read the book several times before. Because Ms. Gabaldon takes so many years before putting out another book in the series, I have re-read them all several times so that I’m not lost. These books are monstrously long, and the plot threads are intricately woven with many people and details.
The first time I read the book, I would have rated it five stars. This time, I find myself reluctant to give it that highest rating, and I’m not quite sure why. Part of it is the length, I think. While I appreciate the fine details and descriptions that place you into the story, I think that some of the day-to-day minutiae could have been eliminated, making for a better paced book.
Also, when I read the book, I skimmed over some of the more explicit love scenes. That is very hard to do when listening to the book on audio - I fast-forwarded some, but it was hard to figure out when that specific scene ended and another scene began. I found myself wishing that Gabaldon had shown a little more restraint in those scenes, simply because I would love to recommend the series to certain readers, but I know they would be put off by the explicitness.
I checked out Dragonfly in Amber on audiobook from the library, and will be starting it soon, after a quick detour into Stephanie Plum-land.
4 out of 5 stars
